Queer Historical Romance Worth Picking Up
When we chose The Lady's Guide to Celestial Mechanics as our book, one question came up again and again at meetings: "What should I read next?" Readers who had never picked up a queer historical romance wanted more, and longtime fans had favorites to share. This is our list, gathered from those conversations.
Why queer historical romance?
Historical romance has always been about people finding love inside rules that were not made for them: class, money, family duty, reputation. Queer historical romance raises those stakes. The characters in these books live in times when their love could cost them their families, their work or their freedom, and the genre still promises them a happy ending. That combination of risk and hope is exactly what made Celestial Mechanics such a good book to talk about.
These stories also push back on a common idea that queer people simply did not exist in the past, or only existed as tragedies. Historians have found plenty of evidence of same-sex love and partnership across the centuries, often hidden in letters and diaries. Romance writers take that evidence and imagine what a happy life could have looked like.
A note on how we chose: every book here is one that readers in our groups recommended or that we love ourselves. We have grouped them by mood and era rather than ranking them.
If you want more of Lucy and Catherine's world
The Care and Feeding of Waspish Widows, by Olivia Waite
The second book in Waite's Feminine Pursuits series moves to the seaside town of Melliton, where Agatha Griffin, a printer, and Penelope Flood, a beekeeper, fall into a later-in-life romance. If what you loved in Celestial Mechanics was women's work taken seriously, this is the obvious next step. Many readers name it as their favorite of the three.
The Hellion's Waltz, by Olivia Waite
The third Feminine Pursuits novel adds a caper to the mix. Its heroine, Sophie Roseingrave, cannot stand a swindler, and the plot that follows combines a con with a grounded sapphic love story. A lively choice for a group that wants a little more plot with its romance.
More sapphic historicals
The Covert Captain, by Jeannelle M. Ferreira
A Regency set after Waterloo. Nathaniel Fleming, a veteran, falls for his major's sister, Harriet, but Nathaniel is not quite what he seems. Reviewers have praised its writing, and its structure, built from short scenes, makes for a good discussion about how romance can be told.
Proper English, by KJ Charles
A country-house shooting party, a murder, and a sapphic romance between Patricia Merton, an expert shot, and Fenella Carruth. It is also a prequel to Charles's Think of England, so if you like it, there is somewhere to go next.
Infamous, by Lex Croucher
A Regency friends-to-lovers story with a modern, comic voice. It is a good pick for readers who want something lighter after the quiet intensity of Celestial Mechanics.
Rogues, highwaymen and gentlemen
The Queer Principles of Kit Webb, by Cat Sebastian
Georgian London, a reformed highwayman and a great deal of forced proximity. Cat Sebastian writes warm, witty historicals, and this one is a favorite starting point.
Provoked, by Joanna Chambers
The first book in the Enlightenment series, set in Edinburgh in the 1820s and told from the point of view of David Lauriston, a lawyer, whose story with the cynical Murdo Balfour runs across several books. Read the series in order.
Something Fabulous, by Alexis Hall
A Regency comedy that knows exactly how ridiculous Regency conventions can be. Hall leans into farce here, so expect laughter more than angst.
Moving into the twentieth century
A Marvellous Light, by Freya Marske
Edwardian England, with magic. A romance and a mystery unfold at a country house where nothing is quite what it seems. Great for readers who also love fantasy.
We Could Be So Good, by Cat Sebastian
Late-1950s New York, a big-city newspaper and Nick Russo, a reporter from Brooklyn, at a time when being openly gay could cost a man everything. It won a Lambda Literary Award and is one of the most recommended queer romances of recent years.
A literary cousin
Tipping the Velvet, by Sarah Waters
Not a genre romance in the strict sense, but a lot of romance readers love it: a sweeping Victorian novel about a young woman from an oyster-selling family who falls for a music-hall performer. If your group likes to compare romance with literary fiction, it starts a great argument.
What to look for in a queer historical
- A world that feels real. The best of these books take the period's dangers seriously without letting them swallow the romance.
- Found family. Friends, siblings and allies who protect the couple are often the heart of the story.
- A believable happy ending. Part of the pleasure is seeing how the author makes a future possible for the couple in their own time.
Reading tips for a group
- Pair two books. Read Celestial Mechanics alongside one of these and compare how each author handles secrecy, family and the risk of being found out.
- Check content notes. Heat levels and difficult themes vary a lot across this list. A quick look before you choose saves surprises.
- Ask your bookseller. Romance-only bookstores and indie stores with strong romance sections are the best source of new recommendations. Our Get the Book page lists the stores we work with.
Need questions for your next meeting? Try our discussion questions for Celestial Mechanics. New to romance in general? Start with romance subgenres for first-time readers. And if you are thinking about starting your own group, read how to start a romance book club in your town.