Brownies and Wine: Book Club Snack Ideas

By The Great Big Romance Read ·

There is a reason the second quote on our home page comes from Jami Attenberg's novel The Middlesteins, and it is about brownies and wine. Food is half of what makes a book club feel like a gathering instead of a seminar. Here is how to feed your romance book club well without spending the whole day in the kitchen.

The ground rules

  • Book-friendly food only. Nothing greasy, nothing drippy, nothing that needs a knife and fork. People will be holding books, turning pages and talking with their hands.
  • Bite-size beats beautiful. Small squares and finger food let people graze through the conversation.
  • Make ahead. The host should be talking about the book, not plating dessert.
  • Something for everyone. At least one alcohol-free drink and at least one snack that works for common allergies.

The brownie question

Every group has its fudgy faction and its cakey faction. Fudgy brownies have more fat and chocolate in proportion to flour, and are dense and moist. Cakey brownies have more flour and often more leavening, so they are lighter and rise more. Whichever side you are on, a few tips:

  • Bake the day before. Most brownies cut more cleanly and taste richer once they have rested overnight.
  • Cut small. A standard rectangular pan cut into small squares feeds a big group, and people can always come back for seconds.
  • Line the pan with parchment with an overhang on two sides. Lift the whole slab out and cut it on a board for neat edges.
  • Add a twist. Flaky salt on top, a swirl of peanut butter or raspberry jam, or a handful of chopped nuts on half the pan so nut-free guests still get a corner.

Wine with chocolate

Chocolate is hard on dry wines; next to something sweet, a dry red can taste thin and bitter. The classic rule for any dessert pairing is that the wine should be at least as sweet as the food. That leaves plenty of good options:

WineWhy it worksBest with
Tawny portNutty, caramel notes and enough sweetness for rich chocolateFudgy brownies, salted caramel
Ruby portRed-fruit flavors that echo berriesBrownies with raspberry swirl
Late-harvest or dessert whiteHoneyed sweetnessLemon bars, shortbread, fruit tarts
Sparkling rosé or BrachettoBubbles and fruit keep things lightMixed dessert platters, strawberries
Off-dry rieslingBright acidity with a touch of sweetnessCheese boards, spiced nuts

If your group prefers a dry red or white with the savory food, serve it first and bring out the dessert wine with the brownies.

Alcohol-free drinks worth the effort

Plenty of readers do not drink, and some venues do not allow alcohol at all. Make the alcohol-free option feel like a choice, not an afterthought:

  • Sparkling cider or sparkling grape juice in real glasses
  • Iced hibiscus tea, which is tart, ruby red and lovely with chocolate
  • A pot of good black tea with milk and sugar on the side, very Regency
  • Hot chocolate for chilly autumn meetings
  • Sparkling water with sliced citrus and mint

A Regency-inspired menu for Celestial Mechanics

If your group is reading our featured book, The Lady's Guide to Celestial Mechanics, lean into its world of drawing rooms and tea:

  • Star-shaped shortbread for the astronomers, dusted with sugar.
  • Seed cake, a caraway-flavored cake that was a teatime staple in Georgian and Victorian England.
  • Lemon curd tartlets, small enough to eat in two bites.
  • Cucumber sandwiches with the crusts cut off, for anyone who needs something savory.
  • Tea, of course, in the prettiest cups you own.

Bring the theme into the conversation, too: our discussion questions for Celestial Mechanics are designed to be read aloud over tea.

Easy savory snacks

  • A cheese board with crackers, grapes and something pickled
  • Spiced or rosemary roasted nuts
  • Crudités with hummus or a yogurt dip
  • A big bowl of popcorn with a couple of toppings to shake on
  • Mini quiches or savory hand pies, which can be made ahead and served at room temperature

Allergies and dietary needs

Ask about allergies when you send the invitation, not on the night. Label anything that contains nuts, gluten or dairy with a small card, keep nut-free food on a separate plate with its own serving utensil, and have at least one option that is vegan or gluten-free. It takes two minutes and makes everyone feel welcome.

A simple timeline for the host

  1. A week before: confirm numbers, ask about allergies and decide what you will make and what others will bring.
  2. Two days before: shop for everything, including ice, napkins and plenty of sparkling water.
  3. The day before: bake the brownies and any shortbread, make dips and chill the wine.
  4. The morning of: cut the brownies, wash fruit and set out plates, glasses and serving utensils.
  5. An hour before: put out the savory food, open the first bottles and set the kettle ready.

Then sit down with your book. The food will look after itself.

Share the work

For a club that meets regularly, a simple sign-up sheet works wonders: one person brings something sweet, one brings something savory, one brings drinks, and the host provides the space and the plates. If you meet at a bookstore or library, check their rules on food and drink before you plan the menu; some spaces allow light snacks only, and many do not allow alcohol.

Planning your first meeting? Our guide to starting a romance book club in your town covers the rest, from finding a venue to choosing questions. You can find groups near you on our participating groups page, and get the book from an independent bookstore.